When I walked into my first board meeting at Informatica, a voice inside my head whispered, "Do they know I don't have an MBA? That I went to a public university? That I'm just a regular person who happened to work hard?" Even after years of proven success in executive roles, that nagging self-doubt was still there. If you've ever felt this way, you're not alone. In fact, you're in excellent company.
The Hidden Reality of Executive Leadership
Here's what might surprise you: that feeling of being an impostor doesn't go away as you climb higher—but you can learn to transform it into your secret weapon. Throughout my journey from middle management to the boardroom, I've discovered that what feels like a weakness can actually become your greatest strength.
Understanding the Self-Doubt Cycle
Self-doubt in leadership typically manifests in three ways:
- Questioning your qualifications despite clear evidence of competence
- Attributing success to external factors rather than your abilities
- Fearing that others will "discover" you're not as capable as they think
The crucial first step is recognizing that these feelings are normal—and they don't define your capability as a leader.
Practical Strategies for Building Confidence
1. Reframe Your Story
Instead of viewing your unconventional path as a weakness, recognize it as a unique strength. My lack of an MBA pushed me to be more practical, results-focused, and relatable as a leader. What aspects of your background might actually be advantages in disguise?
2. Build Your Evidence Bank
Create a documented record of your achievements, positive feedback, and contributions. On challenging days, this tangible evidence can help counter negative self-talk. I keep a folder of emails from team members describing the impact of my leadership—it's powerful ammunition against self-doubt.
3. Use Vulnerability as a Strength
Being authentic about your challenges can make you a more effective leader. When I shared my own career uncertainties with my team at Proofpoint, it opened up honest discussions about growth and created stronger bonds of trust.
Real Stories from the Trenches
During my time scaling Proofpoint from $96M to $700M, I encountered numerous situations that triggered impostor feelings. One particular board presentation stands out. I was the only woman in the room, presenting a major strategic initiative. Instead of letting self-doubt paralyze me, I channeled it into over-preparation and deep understanding of my material. That presentation became a turning point in my career.
Turning Self-Doubt into Action
The key is not to eliminate self-doubt but to harness it:
- Use it as motivation to prepare thoroughly
- Let it drive you to ask better questions
- Allow it to keep you humble and learning
- Transform it into empathy for others facing similar challenges
The Power of Community
Remember: every woman I've mentored who's reached the C-suite has dealt with these feelings. The difference isn't in whether they experience self-doubt—it's in how they handle it.
Moving Forward
Next time that voice of self-doubt speaks up, try this exercise:
- Write down the specific doubt
- List three pieces of evidence that contradict it
- Identify one action you can take to address it
- Share your experience with a trusted mentor or peer
Your Turn
What's your biggest leadership self-doubt? How might you reframe it as a strength? Share your thoughts in the comments below, and let's start a conversation about turning our doubts into stepping stones for success.
__________________________________________________________________________________________